There's been a lot of attention paid recently to the recent New York Times article "How Yoga Can Wreck Your Body," by William Broad. The article is derived from Broad's soon to be released book, Science of Yoga.
Yoga has become tremendously popular in the western world, and its many benefits are backed by numerous articles from the medical and scientific community. Yoga is requested and included in virtually every corporate wellness menu, along with Pilates, and the mainstays of muscle classes such as cycling, dance, and cardio kickboxing. The article spread across the electronic ether like wildfire as many wellness and fitness professionals raised eyebrows and questions about whether we were putting our clients – your employees – in danger of injury, or worse yet, as the article implied, stroke, irreparable nerve damage, and even death.
The goal of successful corporate fitness offerings, including yoga, is to be informed by science and current industry standards. Classes should be beneficial, safe, and approachable for all of your employees; equally and easily appreciated by the sedentary executive assistant, the corporate athlete who needs to better her running time and endurance, and all employees in between.
Liza Forster, regional group fitness director for Plus One, is also a yoga instructor with over 600 hours of training and has offered over 1,000 hours of instruction. She has taught yoga to corporate clients of all levels for nine years, and is also responsible for hiring and evaluating yoga instructors for many of Plus One's corporate facilities across southern California and Seattle.
Forster says, "At Plus One we have a careful screening process for yoga instructors. Just as your employees may look to physical therapists and massage therapists to "fix them," yoga can be trouble when it's taught by the uneducated. Highly dangerous is the instructor who approaches a client, or worse yet, a room full of clients and is unconcerned with form, the limitations, and the student's level of practice. I've fired instructors on the spot who I've seen physically manhandle and manipulate clients beyond their ability. As in any type of movement, that's when people get hurt. Those instructors don't work for our company."
Forster goes on to say, "People look to experts to fix their cars, perform their surgeries, and teach them to ski, but when someone calls themselves a yoga instructor, the buyer must beware the tendency to blindly trust that that person knows what they are doing. Even if the teacher is a master, if they're pushing something that doesn't feel right, or appears dangerous, you have to back off. That's true in so many aspects in life, not just yoga. You don't completely hand over the driver’s wheel of your body to anyone at anytime, nor should anyone ever ask you to. That's common sense."
Ganga White, yoga legend and founder of White Lotus Yoga, (who also happens to be one of Forster's teachers) had his own opinion about Broad's New York Times article. Says White, "A couple months ago I had the good fortune of getting an advance copy of Science of Yoga from William Broad. The publication date is in February and the book is much more balanced than his NYT article. I think it’s a great book with valuable insights and contributions. It is not anti-yoga. Broad is and has been a practicing yogi for years. The book points out what he sees, and what he thinks science has shown, are dangers to be avoided. This doesn’t mean everything the book asserts is true but it initiates a much needed inquiry and debate. Broad’s book also validates many of yoga’s benefits."
Instructors at your corporate wellness facility should be carefully screened and auditioned, by people like Forster who are educated in all modes of movement and fitness. Ideally your instructors are evaluated regularly, and continue to actively seek further education to stay up to date with current science, contraindications, and recommendations.
So don't panic. When in doubt, rely on trained experts and professionals. The final word however, needs to come from the deep part of you that houses your common sense and intuition. In other words, trust yourself.